Handcrafted in Colorado. Ethically Sourced. Gift-Ready
Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $150 away from free shipping.

Graduation Gift Guide

Graduation Gift Ideas

A graduation gift she'll keep — handcrafted birthstone pieces, initial necklaces, and meaningful charms that mark the moment without feeling fussy. Each piece is made to order in Colorado.

Shop birthstone jewelry, initial jewelry, and charms for graduation gift ideas. Each piece is handcrafted to order in our Steamboat Springs, Colorado studio, using recycled 14K gold, gold-fill, or sterling silver and ethically sourced gemstones, and ships in gift-ready packaging — usually within 7 to 10 business days.

Filters

In-stock?
Gemstone
More options
Metal
Color
Price
 
 
 
$
-
$
Birthmonth
More options
Zodiac
Initial
More options
Type
Diamond station necklace in 14k yellow gold with five floating diamonds, elegant everyday jewelry handcrafted for layering.
 
Diamond station necklace in 14k yellow gold with five floating diamonds, elegant everyday jewelry handcrafted for layering.
white gold diamond station necklace styled on model

Diamond Station Necklace

$1,015.00
gigi - cluster earring - erin gallagher Topaz variant--White-Topaz
 
gigi - cluster earring - erin gallagher Topaz variant--White-Topaz
gigi - cluster earring - erin gallagher variant--Citrine
Save up to 40%

gigi - cluster earring

$75.00 $125.00
Custom single charm necklace illustration in gold

Gembar

Design Yours
14k gold-fill paperclip chain necklace, handmade in the USA, perfect for layering or wearing solo. variant--Gold-fill
 
14k gold-fill paperclip chain necklace, handmade in the USA, perfect for layering or wearing solo. variant--Gold-fill
Gold paper clip chain necklace on model — timeless, giftable jewelry for birthdays, anniversaries, or special moments variant--Gold-fill

Paperclip Chain Necklace

From $175.00
Minimalist gold bracelet with elongated oval links for layering variant--Gold-fill
 
Minimalist gold bracelet with elongated oval links for layering variant--Gold-fill
Sterling silver paperclip bracelet styled for layering silver variant--Sterling-silver

Paper-clip chain bracelet

$90.00
basket set diamond stud earrings in 14k gold
 
basket set diamond stud earrings in 14k gold
lab grown diamond stud earrings classic basket setting

Basket-Set Diamond Stud Earrings

From $210.00
Image of custom engagement ring being soldered at jewlers bench

Our top sellers on hand in the studio, perfect for quick gifts or if you're after something ready to wear. All other pieces are handmade to order.

Martini-Set Diamond Studs - erin gallagher variant--14K-white-gold variant--1CT
 
Martini-Set Diamond Studs - erin gallagher variant--14K-white-gold variant--1CT
Martini-Set Diamond Studs - erin gallagher variant--14K-white-gold variant--1CT

Martini-Set Diamond Studs

From $295.00
Custom silk charm bracelet illustration
 
Custom silk charm bracelet illustration
Design your own charm bracelet

Custom Charm Bracelet on Silk

$125.00
Diamond link ring in 14K yellow gold with diamond accents
 
Diamond link ring in 14K yellow gold with diamond accents
Diamond link ring in 14K white gold shown on model

Diamond Link Ring

$975.00
14K gold diamond Star of David necklace with natural diamonds
 
14K gold diamond Star of David necklace with natural diamonds
Diamond Star of David pendant on adjustable cable chain

Diamond Star of David

From $530.00
Design illustration of a Custom two gemstone necklace in 14K gold with hand-cut natural stones
 
Design illustration of a Custom two gemstone necklace in 14K gold with hand-cut natural stones
Birthstone customization options for two-gemstone pendant

'Violet' Custom 2 Gemstone Necklace

From $115.00
white gold huggy diamond hoops
 
white gold huggy diamond hoops
white gold huggy diamond hoops on model

Diamond Huggy Hoops

From $865.00
diamond-tipped open gold ring handmade by Erin gallagher
 
diamond-tipped open gold ring handmade by Erin gallagher
Diamond-Tipped Open Ring

Diamond-Tipped Open Ring

From $600.00
Large paper-clip chain in 14K gold-fill, 16-inch necklace, editorial styling
 
Large paper-clip chain in 14K gold-fill, 16-inch necklace, editorial styling
Large paper-clip chain in 14K gold-fill, 18-inch on model
Sold Out

Large Paper-clip Chain

Sold Out
Pearl Stud Earring - erin gallagher
 
Pearl Stud Earring - erin gallagher
Pearl Stud Earring - erin gallagher

Pearl Stud Earring

$175.00
all-groups, 1/5CTW Trio Diamond Studs - erin gallagher
 
all-groups, 1/5CTW Trio Diamond Studs - erin gallagher
all-groups, 1/5CTW Trio Diamond Studs - erin gallagher

1/5CTW Trio Diamond Studs

$905.00
1/4CT Diamond Stud Earrings - erin gallagher
 
1/4CT Diamond Stud Earrings - erin gallagher
1/4CT Diamond Stud Earrings - erin gallagher variant--Diamond-Nat variant--14K-white-gold
Sold Out

1/4CT Diamond Stud Earrings

Sold Out
Diamond Station Band
 
Diamond Station Band
Diamond Station Band

Diamond Station Band

From $625.00
Marquise diamond stackable band in 14k white gold
 
Marquise diamond stackable band in 14k white gold
Delicate yellow gold marquise diamond stacking ring

Diamond Marquise Stackable Band

From $475.00
yellow gold diamond horseshoe necklace
 
yellow gold diamond horseshoe necklace
diamond horseshoe necklace in yellow gold on model variant--14K-yellow-gold variant--14K-white-gold variant--14K-rose-gold

Diamond Horseshoe Necklace

$1,235.00
Diamond chevron ring in 14K yellow gold with natural diamonds variant--14K-yellow-gold
 
Diamond chevron ring in 14K yellow gold with natural diamonds variant--14K-yellow-gold
Chevron diamond band with subtle sparkle variant--14K-yellow-gold

Diamond Chevron Ring

From $1,020.00
1/5CT martini-set diamond stud earrings in 14K white gold, product view
 
1/5CT martini-set diamond stud earrings in 14K white gold, product view
1/5CT martini-set diamond studs in 14K white gold, on model

1/5CT Martini-Set Diamond Studs

$585.00
Lowercase Initial Charm - erin gallagher
 
Lowercase Initial Charm - erin gallagher
Lowercase Initial Charm - erin gallagher

Lowercase Initial Charm

From $35.00
Diamond lowercase initial pendant necklace close up
 
Diamond lowercase initial pendant necklace close up
Personalized diamond initial necklace layered look

Diamond Lowercase Initial Necklace

From $735.00
Custom Initials Necklace
 
Custom Initials Necklace
Custom Initials Necklace

Custom Initials Necklace

$695.00

Graduation Gift Guide

Discover the Perfect Graduation Gift

Explore our exclusive collection of hand-made jewelry, crafted in the United States using conflict-free stones and recycled metals. Celebrate your graduate with timeless elegance and eco-friendly packaging, making their special day unforgettable.