Handcrafted in Colorado. Ethically Sourced. Gift-Ready
Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $150 away from free shipping.

Engagement Rings

Gift-ready packaging | Hand-made in CO | Free shipping over $150

Filters

In-stock?
Gemstone
Metal
Color
Price
 
 
 
$
-
$
Birthmonth
Type
View 32 items
Milgrain vintage engagement ring setting in 14K gold, front view
 
Milgrain vintage engagement ring setting in 14K gold, front view
Milgrain vintage engagement ring on model hand

Milgrain Vintage Engagement Ring Setting

From $1,500.00
Vintage diamond engagement ring setting in 14K gold, front view variant--14K-rose-gold variant--14K-white-gold variant--14K-yellow-gold variant--Diamond
 
Vintage diamond engagement ring setting in 14K gold, front view variant--14K-rose-gold variant--14K-white-gold variant--14K-yellow-gold variant--Diamond
Vintage diamond engagement ring setting in 14K gold, three-quarter angle variant--14K-rose-gold variant--14K-white-gold variant--14K-yellow-gold variant--Diamond

Vintage Diamond Engagement Ring Setting

From $1,710.00
Custom single charm necklace illustration in gold

Gembar

Design Yours
Diamond cluster engagement ring setting in 14K yellow gold
 
Diamond cluster engagement ring setting in 14K yellow gold
Pear and round diamond engagement ring setting

Diamond Cluster Engagement Ring Setting

From $1,545.00
Vintage diamond halo engagement ring in 14K gold, diamond center, front view
 
Vintage diamond halo engagement ring in 14K gold, diamond center, front view
Vintage diamond halo engagement ring in 14K gold, diamond center, three-quarter angle

Vintage Diamond Halo Engagement Ring Setting

From $1,390.00
Milgrain bezel-set diamond engagement ring setting in 14K gold, front view
 
Milgrain bezel-set diamond engagement ring setting in 14K gold, front view
Milgrain bezel engagement ring on model hand, styled shot

Milgrain Bezel-Set Diamond Engagement Ring Setting

From $1,275.00
Image of custom engagement ring being soldered at jewlers bench

Our top sellers on hand in the studio, perfect for quick gifts or if you're after something ready to wear. All other pieces are handmade to order.

Saddle halo diamond engagement ring setting in 14K gold, diamond center, front view
 
Saddle halo diamond engagement ring setting in 14K gold, diamond center, front view
Saddle halo diamond engagement ring setting in 14K gold, diamond center, three-quarter angle

Saddle Halo Diamond Engagement Ring Setting

From $1,425.00
Floral halo diamond engagement ring with emerald-cut center in 14K gold, editorial view
 
Floral halo diamond engagement ring with emerald-cut center in 14K gold, editorial view
Floral halo engagement ring on model showing scale and sparkle

Floral Halo Diamond Engagement Ring Setting

From $1,845.00
Floral cluster diamond engagement ring in 14K gold, top view showing petal-like diamond arrangement
 
Floral cluster diamond engagement ring in 14K gold, top view showing petal-like diamond arrangement
Floral cluster diamond engagement ring in 14K gold, angled view of floral setting

Floral Cluster Diamond Engagement Ring

From $1,520.00
Three-stone baguette side stone ring in 14K gold, diamond center, front view
 
Three-stone baguette side stone ring in 14K gold, diamond center, front view
Three-stone baguette side stone ring in 14K gold, diamond center, three-quarter angle variant--Round variant--1CT variant--14K-yellow-gold

Three-Stone Setting with Baguette-Cut Side Stones

From $6,735.00
East-west matching diamond wedding band in 14K gold, showing curved contour profile variant--Diamond variant--14K-yellow-gold variant--14K-white-gold variant--14K-rose-gold
 
East-west matching diamond wedding band in 14K gold, showing curved contour profile variant--Diamond variant--14K-yellow-gold variant--14K-white-gold variant--14K-rose-gold
14K white gold French-Set East-West Diamond Halo Matching Wedding Band variant--14K-white-gold variant--Diamond

French-Set East-West Diamond Halo Matching Wedding Band

From $2,320.00
East-west French-set diamond halo engagement ring with emerald-cut center, editorial view
 
East-west French-set diamond halo engagement ring with emerald-cut center, editorial view
East-west French-set halo engagement ring in 14K gold showing horizontal center stone orientation variant--14K-white-gold variant--Diamond-Lab variant--Diamond-Nat

French-Set East-West Diamond Halo Engagement Ring Setting

From $2,220.00
Scroll solitaire engagement ring in 14K gold, diamond center, front view
 
Scroll solitaire engagement ring in 14K gold, diamond center, front view
Scroll solitaire engagement ring in 14K gold, diamond center, three-quarter angle

Scroll Solitaire Engagement Ring

From $680.00
Scalloped halo diamond engagement ring in 14K gold, diamond center, front view
 
Scalloped halo diamond engagement ring in 14K gold, diamond center, front view
Scalloped halo diamond engagement ring in 14K gold, diamond center, three-quarter angle

Scalloped Halo Diamond Engagement Ring

From $1,285.00
14K yellow gold double claw prong solitaire engagement ring setting
 
14K yellow gold double claw prong solitaire engagement ring setting
14K white gold double claw prong solitaire engagement ring on model

Double Claw Prong Solitaire Engagement Ring

From $655.00
Diamond burst engagement ring setting white gold
 
Diamond burst engagement ring setting white gold
https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0566/1478/1015/files/123996_ed.jpg?v=1725246223

Diamond Burst Engagement Ring

From $3,020.00
Three-stone engagement ring with round side stones in 14K gold, diamond center, front view
 
Three-stone engagement ring with round side stones in 14K gold, diamond center, front view
Three-stone engagement ring with round side stones in 14K gold, diamond center, three-quarter angle

Three-Stone Engagement Ring Setting

From $1,470.00
Claw-prong diamond solitaire engagement ring setting in 14K yellow gold
 
Claw-prong diamond solitaire engagement ring setting in 14K yellow gold
Claw-prong solitaire engagement ring setting in 14K yellow gold shown on model

Claw-Prong Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring

From $695.00
Bezel-set East West engagement ring setting in 14K gold
 
Bezel-set East West engagement ring setting in 14K gold
Modern East West engagement ring with baguette diamonds

Bezel-Set-East West Engagement Ring Setting

From $1,855.00
Diamond halo engagement ring setting in 14K white gold
 
Diamond halo engagement ring setting in 14K white gold
White gold halo engagement ring with lab-grown diamonds

Diamond Halo Engagement Ring

From $1,530.00
Bottom halo engagement ring setting with hidden diamonds
 
Bottom halo engagement ring setting with hidden diamonds
Hidden halo engagement ring profile view in 14K gold

Bottom Halo Engagement Ring Setting

From $1,410.00
Diamond cluster engagement ring setting with round accent diamonds
 
Diamond cluster engagement ring setting with round accent diamonds
Modern cluster accent engagement ring setting shown on model

Diamond Cluster Accent Stone Engagement Ring Setting

From $1,155.00
Modern hexagon engagement ring setting in 14K gold, front view variant--14K-rose-gold variant--14K-white-gold variant--14K-yellow-gold
 
Modern hexagon engagement ring setting in 14K gold, front view variant--14K-rose-gold variant--14K-white-gold variant--14K-yellow-gold
Hexagon engagement ring setting, angled view showing baguette accents variant--14K-yellow-gold

Modern Hexagon Engagement Ring Setting

From $1,455.00
French-set halo engagement ring setting in 14K gold, product view showing halo detail
 
French-set halo engagement ring setting in 14K gold, product view showing halo detail
French-set halo engagement ring editorial close-up of French-set diamond surround

French-Set Halo-Style Engagement Ring Setting

From $1,755.00
Three-stone engagement ring with pear side stones in 14K gold, diamond center, front view
 
Three-stone engagement ring with pear side stones in 14K gold, diamond center, front view
Three-stone engagement ring with pear side stones in 14K gold, diamond center, three-quarter angle

Three-Stone Engagement Ring Setting with Pear-cut Side Stones

From $1,250.00

Engagement Rings

Engagement Rings

More Than a Ring, A Story
An engagement ring is more than jewelry—it’s a promise, a beginning, and a reflection of your love story. At Erin Gallagher Jewelry, we create engagement rings that are as personal as they are timeless, crafted with intention and designed to be cherished for generations.

Why Choose an Erin Gallagher Engagement Ring?

Every engagement ring we create is handcrafted in the USA using ethically sourced diamonds or gemstones and recycled precious metals. With over 20 years of award-winning design experience, Erin Gallagher is known for blending quiet luxury with modern heirloom design, ensuring that your ring is as unique as your love story.

Styles of Engagement Rings

  • Solitaire Engagement Rings: Classic and timeless, highlighting the brilliance of a single stone.
  • Halo Engagement Rings: Vintage-inspired sparkle with diamonds encircling the center gem.
  • Three-Stone Rings: Symbolizing past, present, and future in one meaningful design.
  • Alternative Stones: Sapphires, moissanite, and salt-and-pepper diamonds for non-traditional beauty.
  • Custom Engagement Rings: Bespoke designs tailored to your story, from gemstone to engraving.

The Custom Process

Our engagement ring process is personal, collaborative, and transparent. Whether you’re local to Steamboat Springs or working with us virtually, we guide you step by step—from the initial inspiration to the final polish—making the experience as meaningful as the ring itself.

Designed to Last a Lifetime

We believe the perfect ring isn’t about trend—it’s about meaning. Our heirloom-quality engagement rings are created to be loved now, treasured for a lifetime, and passed down as a reflection of your story.

Explore our engagement ring collection and discover the ring that reflects your forever.