Handcrafted in Colorado. Ethically Sourced. Gift-Ready

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $150 away from free shipping.

Gifts Under $200

Thoughtful Gifts Under $200

Meaningful, handcrafted jewelry that fits a smaller budget — birthstone charms, initial necklaces, gold-fill pieces, and more. Each gift arrives in our signature gift-ready packaging.

Browse birthstone jewelry, initial jewelry, and charms for ideas under $200.

Filters

In-stock?
Gemstone
Metal
Color
Price
 
 
 
$
-
$
Birthmonth
Zodiac
Initial
Type
'Trista' Birthstone Necklace - erin gallagher
 
'Trista' Birthstone Necklace - erin gallagher
Natural white topaz pendant necklace in sterling silver, close-up of setting in sterling silver

'Trista' Birthstone Necklace

$135.00
Diamond compass charm in 14K yellow gold
 
Diamond compass charm in 14K yellow gold
Diamond compass charm with four diamond accents shown on model

Diamond Compass Charm

From $190.00
Diamond pavé star charm in 14K yellow gold, front view variant--14K-yellow-gold
 
Diamond pavé star charm in 14K yellow gold, front view variant--14K-yellow-gold
Diamond pavé star charm in 14K white gold, front view variant--14K-white-gold

Diamond Pave Star Charm

From $190.00
Nana Charm - erin gallagher variant--14K-white-gold
 
Nana Charm - erin gallagher variant--14K-white-gold
Nana Charm - erin gallagher variant--14K-white-gold

Nana Charm

From $55.00
Mama Charm - erin gallagher
 
Mama Charm - erin gallagher
Mama Charm - erin gallagher

Mama Charm

From $55.00
variant--group
 
variant--group
Birthstone dangle earrings shown on model variant--Gold-fill variant--Sterling-silver variant--Swiss-Topaz

Birthstone Dangle Earrings

$155.00
variant--cameron-video
 
variant--cameron-video
variant--group

Birthstone Drop Earring

From $95.00
variant--Charm
 
variant--Charm
variant--Charm

Fireman's Charm or Necklace

From $75.00
Gold wave ring in 14K yellow gold, sculptural front product view
 
Gold wave ring in 14K yellow gold, sculptural front product view
Gold wave ring on model, styled close-up showing width

Gold Wave Ring

From $180.00
Sterling silver Lowercase A Initial Charm variant--A variant--Sterling-silver variant--14K-white-gold
 
Sterling silver Lowercase A Initial Charm variant--A variant--Sterling-silver variant--14K-white-gold
14K yellow gold Lowercase A Initial Charm variant--A variant--14K-yellow-gold

Lowercase Letter Charm

From $15.00
Baguette diamond contour band in 14K gold
 
Baguette diamond contour band in 14K gold
Tapered baguette diamond curved wedding band(Lab)-/-Apr(CZ/Brass) variant--14K-yellow-gold variant--Diamond-Nat variant--Diamond-Lab variant--CZ-Try-on-At-Home

Baguette Diamond Contour Band

From $150.00
curved diamond wedding band with arabesque design
 
curved diamond wedding band with arabesque design
arabesque curved diamond band in 14k gold stacked with other bands on models hand

Arabesque Curved Diamond Band

From $150.00
Oval birthstone necklace variant--none
 
Oval birthstone necklace variant--none
Garnet necklace in sterling silver with east-west prong setting variant--Sterling-silver variant--Garnet

East West Oval Birthstone Necklace

From $180.00
WWJD Charm - erin gallagher variant--14K-yellow-gold
 
WWJD Charm - erin gallagher variant--14K-yellow-gold
WWJD Charm - erin gallagher variant--14K-yellow-gold

WWJD Charm

From $60.00
#VALUE!
 
#VALUE!
Engraved Lock Necklace

Engraved Lock Necklace

$175.00
Four Leaf Clover Charm - erin gallagher
 
Four Leaf Clover Charm - erin gallagher
Four Leaf Clover Charm - erin gallagher

Four Leaf Clover Charm

From $60.00
Lowercase Initial Charm - erin gallagher
 
Lowercase Initial Charm - erin gallagher
Lowercase Initial Charm - erin gallagher

Lowercase Initial Charm

From $35.00
illustration of custom engraving on white gold heart pendant
 
illustration of custom engraving on white gold heart pendant
14K yellow gold engraved heart necklace front view

Engraved Heart Necklace

$175.00
Large paper-clip chain in 14K gold-fill, 16-inch necklace, editorial styling
 
Large paper-clip chain in 14K gold-fill, 16-inch necklace, editorial styling
Large paper-clip chain in 14K gold-fill, 18-inch on model
Sold Out
Namaste Charm - erin gallagher
 
Namaste Charm - erin gallagher
Namaste Charm - erin gallagher

Namaste Charm

From $65.00
Engravable Disc Bracelet - erin gallagher
 
Engravable Disc Bracelet - erin gallagher
Engravable Disc Bracelet - erin gallagher

Engravable Disc Bracelet

From $77.00
#VALUE!
 
#VALUE!
Engravable Disc Charm - erin gallagher

Engravable Disc Charm

$145.00
#VALUE!
 
#VALUE!
Engraved Mini Dog Tag Charm

Engraved Mini Dog Tag Charm

$145.00
Happy Charm - erin gallagher
 
Happy Charm - erin gallagher
Happy Charm - erin gallagher

Happy Charm

From $60.00

Gifts Under $200

Jewelry Gifts Under $200

Discover handcrafted jewelry gifts under $200—custom earrings, necklaces, and charms made in the USA with recycled gold and silver. Beautifully packaged, ready to gift.

Meaningful. Beautiful. Budget-Friendly.

Finding the perfect jewelry gift doesn’t have to mean spending a fortune. Our curated collection of jewelry gifts under $200 features timeless pieces designed to delight—without compromising on quality or style.

Whether you're shopping for a birthday, anniversary, graduation, or just a little something to say “I'm thinking of you”, these affordable treasures are made to be worn, loved, and remembered.

What You'll Find in Our Under $200 Collection:

Earrings Under $200

From minimalist studs to eye-catching gemstone drops, our earrings are handcrafted using sterling silver, 14K gold, and ethically sourced stones. Perfect for everyday wear or as a finishing touch to something special.

  • Dainty diamond studs
  • Custom birthstone drops
  • Hoops & huggies in silver or gold
  • Statement gemstone earrings

Necklaces Under $200

Give a gift they’ll wear every day. Our necklaces include engraved pendants, birthstone charms, and chain layering styles—all handmade and designed to be meaningful.

  • Engravable bar necklaces
  • Single gemstone pendants
  • Paperclip and satellite chains
  • Custom initial and birthstone combos

Gifts With Meaning That Won’t Break the Bank

Every piece in this collection is:

  • Handcrafted in the USA
  • Made with recycled gold or silver
  • Designed for sentiment and longevity
  • Packaged in our signature gift-ready box, tied with a grosgrain ribbon

Whether you're buying for a best friend, your sister, your mom, or yourself, our under-$200 jewelry proves you don’t need to spend a lot to give something truly special.