Handcrafted in Colorado. Ethically Sourced. Gift-Ready

Congratulations! Your order qualifies for free shipping You are $150 away from free shipping.

Gifts Under $200

Thoughtful Gifts Under $200

Meaningful, handcrafted jewelry that fits a smaller budget — birthstone charms, initial necklaces, gold-fill pieces, and more. Each gift arrives in our signature gift-ready packaging.

Browse birthstone jewelry, initial jewelry, and charms for ideas under $200.

Filters

In-stock?
Gemstone
Metal
Color
Price
 
 
 
$
-
$
Birthmonth
Zodiac
Initial
Type
Custom 4 gemstone necklace design illustration with birthstones
 
Custom 4 gemstone necklace design illustration with birthstones
Custom 4 gemstone necklace in gold with blue topaz and citrine stones

Jordan Custom Gemstone Necklace

$155.00
Custom gemstone bracelet illustration showing chrysoprase in gold-fill
 
Custom gemstone bracelet illustration showing chrysoprase in gold-fill
Custom gemstone bracelet with chrysoprase stone in gold-fill, product photo

Custom Gemstone Bracelet

$155.00
Design illustration of a Custom two gemstone necklace in 14K gold with hand-cut natural stones
 
Design illustration of a Custom two gemstone necklace in 14K gold with hand-cut natural stones
Birthstone customization options for two-gemstone pendant

'Violet' Custom 2 Gemstone Necklace

From $115.00
Tiny Gem Choker Necklace - erin gallagher variant--Pearl
 
Tiny Gem Choker Necklace - erin gallagher variant--Pearl
Apatite Tiny Gem Choker Necklace - erin gallagher variant--Pearl
Save up to 50%

Tiny Gem Necklace

From $75.00 $125.00
White Pearl Stretch Bracelet - erin gallagher variant--Pearl
 
White Pearl Stretch Bracelet - erin gallagher variant--Pearl
White Pearl Stretch Bracelet - erin gallagher variant--Pearl

Stretch Bracelet with Diamond Accents

$145.00
"Love" Charm - erin gallagher variant--14K-yellow-gold
 
"Love" Charm - erin gallagher variant--14K-yellow-gold
"Love" Charm - erin gallagher variant--14K-white-gold variant--Sterling-silver

"Love" Charm

From $165.00
Bubble letter initial A charm in recycled 14K gold variant--A variant--14K-yellow-gold
 
Bubble letter initial A charm in recycled 14K gold variant--A variant--14K-yellow-gold
Personalized initial charm in gold or sterling silver layered on model variant--A variant--14K-yellow-gold

Bubble Letter Charm

From $50.00
Fearless Charm - erin gallagher variant--Sterling-silver variant--14K-white-gold
 
Fearless Charm - erin gallagher variant--Sterling-silver variant--14K-white-gold
Fearless Charm - erin gallagher variant--14K-yellow-gold

Fearless Charm

From $145.00
Puffy Heart Charm - erin gallagher variant--14K-yellow-gold
 
Puffy Heart Charm - erin gallagher variant--14K-yellow-gold
Puffy Heart Charm - erin gallagher variant--14K-white-gold variant--Sterling-silver

Puffy Heart Charm

From $55.00
Stackable Birthstone Ring - erin gallagher
 
Stackable Birthstone Ring - erin gallagher
Stackable Birthstone Ring - erin gallagher

Stackable Birthstone Ring

From $155.00
Oval Signet Monogram Ring - erin gallagher
 
Oval Signet Monogram Ring - erin gallagher
Oval Signet Monogram Ring - erin gallagher variant--Sterling-silver

Oval Signet Monogram Ring

From $120.00
Emerald-cut birthstone necklace on 18-inch gold cable chain, editorial styling
 
Emerald-cut birthstone necklace on 18-inch gold cable chain, editorial styling
Minimalist birthstone necklace featuring a 5x3mm emerald shown on model

Emerald-cut Birthstone Necklace

From $145.00
Trio Stud Earring - erin gallagher
 
Trio Stud Earring - erin gallagher
Trio Stud Earring - erin gallagher

Trio Stud Earring

From $175.00
#VALUE!
 
#VALUE!
Cancer jewelry collection featuring designs for the Cancer zodiac sign

Zodiac Medallion Charm

From $175.00
east west garnet necklace in bezel-set 14K yellow gold variant--14K-yellow-gold variant--14K-white-gold variant--14K-rose-gold variant--Sterling-silver variant--Garnet
 
east west garnet necklace in bezel-set 14K yellow gold variant--14K-yellow-gold variant--14K-white-gold variant--14K-rose-gold variant--Sterling-silver variant--Garnet
Minimalist garnet necklace featuring a 8x10mm emerald shown on model variant--14K-yellow-gold variant--14K-white-gold variant--14K-rose-gold variant--Sterling-silver variant--Garnet
Charm clustered with other birthstones on a chain — family story
 
Charm clustered with other birthstones on a chain — family story
Minimalist birthstone charm 14K gold USA

3mm Birthstone Prong Charm

From $135.00
Slide image
 
Bezel-set Birthstone Bracelet
14K yellow gold Sapphire bracelet, Bezel-set sapphire bracelet in 14K yellow gold on adjustable curb chain variant--14K-yellow-gold variant--Sapphire

Bezel-set Birthstone Bracelet

From $145.00
Aries zodiac charm in 14K yellow gold with .01ct diamond
 
Aries zodiac charm in 14K yellow gold with .01ct diamond
Zodiac charms with engraved design and diamond

Diamond Zodiac Charm

From $155.00
Rounded box chain in sterling silver, front view variant--Sterling-silver variant--8in variant--18in variant--20in variant--24in
 
Rounded box chain in sterling silver, front view variant--Sterling-silver variant--8in variant--18in variant--20in variant--24in
Rounded box chain in sterling silver, showing rounded box links variant--Sterling-silver variant--8in variant--18in variant--20in variant--24in

Rounded Box Chain

From $95.00
Zodiac pendants in gold with birthstones and diamond constellation styled layed flat
 
Zodiac pendants in gold with birthstones and diamond constellation styled layed flat
constellation necklace with diamonds and birthstone on gold chain styled on model

Zodiac Constellation Charm Necklace

From $200.00
Zodiac Gemstone Charm Necklace - erin gallagher(Mar-21---Apr-19) variant--Aries variant--14K-rose-gold
 
Zodiac Gemstone Charm Necklace - erin gallagher(Mar-21---Apr-19) variant--Aries variant--14K-rose-gold
Zodiac Gemstone Charm Necklace - erin gallagher(Apr-20---May-20) variant--Taurus variant--14K-rose-gold

Zodiac Gemstone Charm Necklace

From $125.00
Gemstone Zodiac Charm - erin gallagher(Mar-21---Apr-19) variant--Aries variant--14K-yellow-gold
 
Gemstone Zodiac Charm - erin gallagher(Mar-21---Apr-19) variant--Aries variant--14K-yellow-gold
Gemstone Zodiac Charm - erin gallagher(Jan-20---Feb-18) variant--Aquarius variant--14K-rose-gold

Gemstone Zodiac Charm

From $85.00
Gift-ready custom gemstone bracelet with eco-friendly packaging
 
Gift-ready custom gemstone bracelet with eco-friendly packaging
Natural garnet woven chain bracelet in 14K gold-fill, close-up of setting variant--Garnet variant--Gold-fill

Birthstone Bracelet

$135.00
Single Drop Birthstone Necklaces in 14K gold and silver
 
Single Drop Birthstone Necklaces in 14K gold and silver
Minimal white topaz pendant necklace with bright, diamond-like sparkle on model

Birthstone Drop Necklace

From $95.00

Gifts Under $200

Jewelry Gifts Under $200

Discover handcrafted jewelry gifts under $200—custom earrings, necklaces, and charms made in the USA with recycled gold and silver. Beautifully packaged, ready to gift.

Meaningful. Beautiful. Budget-Friendly.

Finding the perfect jewelry gift doesn’t have to mean spending a fortune. Our curated collection of jewelry gifts under $200 features timeless pieces designed to delight—without compromising on quality or style.

Whether you're shopping for a birthday, anniversary, graduation, or just a little something to say “I'm thinking of you”, these affordable treasures are made to be worn, loved, and remembered.

What You'll Find in Our Under $200 Collection:

Earrings Under $200

From minimalist studs to eye-catching gemstone drops, our earrings are handcrafted using sterling silver, 14K gold, and ethically sourced stones. Perfect for everyday wear or as a finishing touch to something special.

  • Dainty diamond studs
  • Custom birthstone drops
  • Hoops & huggies in silver or gold
  • Statement gemstone earrings

Necklaces Under $200

Give a gift they’ll wear every day. Our necklaces include engraved pendants, birthstone charms, and chain layering styles—all handmade and designed to be meaningful.

  • Engravable bar necklaces
  • Single gemstone pendants
  • Paperclip and satellite chains
  • Custom initial and birthstone combos

Gifts With Meaning That Won’t Break the Bank

Every piece in this collection is:

  • Handcrafted in the USA
  • Made with recycled gold or silver
  • Designed for sentiment and longevity
  • Packaged in our signature gift-ready box, tied with a grosgrain ribbon

Whether you're buying for a best friend, your sister, your mom, or yourself, our under-$200 jewelry proves you don’t need to spend a lot to give something truly special.